Skip to content

weaviate/collections/classes/filters.py: an empty tuple passes equal() and five other filter builders, so the empty-list error only appears when the query runs #2265

Open

Description

@dirkkul

An empty tuple passes Filter.by_property(...).equal(()) and five sibling builders, while an empty list fails on the same call. The tuple's error appears only later, when a query converts the filter into its gRPC request.

Failure

_FilterByProperty.equal() builds the filter object a query later sends. It rejects an empty value only when isinstance(val, list) holds, so [] raises WeaviateInvalidInputError and () returns a filter. not_equal, less_than, less_or_equal, greater_than and greater_or_equal repeat the same check. FilterValuesList is typed as Sequence[...], so a type checker accepts the tuple.

One run on main at 200b57e:

  1. A caller writes f = Filter.by_property("tags").equal(()). Nothing raises, and f holds the empty tuple.
  2. Later, collection.query.fetch_objects(filters=f) builds its request. It calls _FilterToGRPC.convert(filters) at weaviate/collections/grpc/query.py:517, which turns a filter object into its protobuf message.
  3. _FilterToGRPC.__value_filter converts any non-string sequence to a list with _to_value_list and finds it empty. It raises WeaviateInvalidInputError: Filtering on empty lists is not supported by Weaviate.

The caller sees the right message, but the traceback points at fetch_objects instead of the line that built the filter. With equal([]) the same message points at equal(). Code that builds filters in one module and runs queries in another has to trace the tuple back by hand.

Reachability

Reachable. Any caller of the public Filter.by_property(...) API can pass an empty tuple, and nothing between that call and equal() converts it.

Severity

Low. The message is correct and no request reaches the server. Only the point where the error is raised is wrong.

Location

weaviate/collections/classes/filters.py:225, with the same check at :235, :245, :255, :269 and :283.

if isinstance(val, list) and len(val) == 0:

Excerpt

    def equal(self, val: FilterValues) -> _Filters:
        """Filter on whether the property is equal to the given value."""
        if isinstance(val, list) and len(val) == 0:
            raise WeaviateInvalidInputError(
                "Filtering on empty lists is not supported by Weaviate. "
                "To filter by property length, use "
                "Filter.by_property('prop', length=True).equal(0)"
            )
        return _FilterValue(target=self._target_path(), value=val, operator=_Operator.EQUAL)

Reproduction

No server is needed. The script calls _FilterToGRPC.convert, the same call fetch_objects makes at grpc/query.py:517.

from weaviate.classes.query import Filter
from weaviate.collections.filters import _FilterToGRPC
from weaviate.exceptions import WeaviateInvalidInputError

for name in ["equal", "not_equal", "less_than", "less_or_equal", "greater_than", "greater_or_equal"]:
    for val in ([], ()):
        try:
            getattr(Filter.by_property("tags"), name)(val)
            print(f"{name}({val!r}): builder accepted it")
        except WeaviateInvalidInputError:
            print(f"{name}({val!r}): builder raised WeaviateInvalidInputError")

f = Filter.by_property("tags").equal(())
try:
    _FilterToGRPC.convert(f)
except WeaviateInvalidInputError as e:
    print("convert raised WeaviateInvalidInputError:", e)

Run from the repository root with PYTHONPATH=. python repro.py on 200b57e. It prints:

equal([]): builder raised WeaviateInvalidInputError
equal(()): builder accepted it
not_equal([]): builder raised WeaviateInvalidInputError
not_equal(()): builder accepted it
less_than([]): builder raised WeaviateInvalidInputError
less_than(()): builder accepted it
less_or_equal([]): builder raised WeaviateInvalidInputError
less_or_equal(()): builder accepted it
greater_than([]): builder raised WeaviateInvalidInputError
greater_than(()): builder accepted it
greater_or_equal([]): builder raised WeaviateInvalidInputError
greater_or_equal(()): builder accepted it
convert raised WeaviateInvalidInputError: Invalid input provided: Filtering on empty lists is not supported by Weaviate. To filter by property length, use Filter.by_property('prop', length=True).equal(0).

Suggested fix

In weaviate/collections/classes/filters.py, change the six checks to match any non-string sequence, the way _to_value_list in weaviate/collections/filters.py:23 does:

if isinstance(val, Sequence) and not isinstance(val, (str, bytes)) and len(val) == 0:

Keep the str and bytes exclusion, since equal("") is a valid filter on an empty string. A unit test asserting that each of the six methods raises WeaviateInvalidInputError for () confirms the fix. The six copies of the check could also become one helper.

Provenance

Pre-existing. The six checks come from 5cb7e1a (2026-02-12, "Fix empty list filter raising IndexError instead of WeaviateInvalidInputError"). #2169 (142d798..200b57e) changed only weaviate/collections/filters.py and its tests. Before #2169, the serializer also checked only for list, so the tuple reached the server as a filter with no value set. #2169 made the serializer reject it with the right message. Its description says it chose not to patch the builder methods. The closed #933 asked for this exception on empty lists.

Verification

Confirmed by the reproduction above on 200b57e, which is on main since #2169 merged.

Where it surfaced

Review of #2169 (fix/filter-accepts-sequence-values, base main).

Activity

  1. vinayakudale2-web commented on Nov 18, 2026

    @vinayakudale2-web

    Hi! I'd like to work on this issue as my next open-source contribution. Could you please let me know if I can take it up?

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    bugSomething isn't working

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions